Search results

So they are guilty because they were there? They deserve to be locked up without trial for an indefinite length of time because they didn't help the US? Like I have tried to say before, try them for whatever crimes they have commited or let them go. It really is that simple.

We can assume it because of the amount of WMDs you've found littering Iraq?

So we can take it as read that because these people were in and around Afghanistan/Iraq they are terrorists. Maybe they all had WMDs too...

Better kill them all then. Incidentally did there used to be a link there? All I can see is a post that doesn't mention the age of this man's son...

I can only assume you mean that these people are being held because of the attacks on the US. The people in custody were all captured in and around Afghanistan, they have not been proven to be linked to the 9/11 attacks in any way. Show me where you mentioned it in this thread and I will...

Sorry, my assumption. Should have learned not to do that by now.

Please tell me I've got hold of the wrong end of the stick because that looks like you are saying you've been in the same situation? Sorry, I missed it you saying that. Was it in a different thread? I can't find it here. How do they violate international law btw?

Why are you so clear on the fact that all of them were combatants despite all of the conflicting evidence?

So you believe these people must be international terrorists and deserve to be locked up indefinitely without any form of trial? How have you come to this decision?

I know you usually seem to make up your own mind based on the facts, which makes it all the more strange when you do accept the bullshit without questioning it.

The thing that makes me doubt this is that your government is unwilling to follow international law. Quite simply they won't put their money where their mouth is. I am sure that they believe these people to be a threat but if they have actually done nothing wrong then they should never...

Just how do you know the prisoners are terrorists? If Bush started selling cow shit and called it burgers would you eat it?

Re: Enough with Fuhrer derives from the Old High German - "Fuoren" meaning to lead or guide it doesn't mean Father.

You can tell someone's deepest beliefs simply through a very short sarcastic post? Coooooooooooooooooooooooool...

That is exactly my point. We have been told that these people are dangerous terrorists, yet they have not been charged with any crime, we have been told they are enemy combatants in the war in Afghanistan yet they haven't been declared POWs, we have been told absolutely fuck all except that you...

I love it! :D

WTF? They haven't been tried or even accused of a crime, how is this the same? and if I kidnap you you are a prisoner and there is a reason for it. That doesn't make it in anyway legal though. Technically no, they have never been officially declared as POWs and therefore in the eyes of the...

So you return those that claim asylum and keep those that want releasing? You're surprised people think you're out of order?

Not far off actually...

and now I look aren't IE and Windows both MS?